PitchCentric
It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast
Updated 9 days ago · Refreshed hourly
christianity

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast

Hosted by North American Mission Board · 🇺🇸 US · EN · 13 episodes

Where this show ranks

Episodes
13
Last ep.
9 days ago
Booking Probability™
28
Stretch.
Sign in to score against your profile.
Estimated audience
,
Audience size not yet estimated
Listen Score
16
Niche reach.
Virality (30d)
47
Steady cadence.

Pitch Analysis

Sign in to see how your Guest Score compares to this show's Required Pod Score and get a Stretch / Match-fit / Anchor verdict.
Required Pod Score
80/ 100
Premium

Established thought leaders with verified media credentials.

Guest openness
Not signalled recently
Best topics to pitch
christianity

About this podcast

Welcome to the It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast with hosts Matt Capps and Josh Reavis, where you’ll hear unforgettable, awkward, and hilarious stories that could truly only happen to a pastor. Think mic mishaps, baptism bloopers, and kids saying the worst possible thing mid-sermon. So, if you need a laugh or just a little encouragement along the way from pastors just like you, listen in today!

christianity

About the host

North American Mission Board hosts It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast, a christianity show with 13 episodes published.

Recent episodes

Our AI reads these to draft pitches

Top 5 Pastor Hacks

Apr 13, 20260Ep. 12S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a countdown of their Top 5 “Pastor Hacks”—from the strategically deployed trailer hitch handshake to a well-timed “mic off” moment tha

Show notes

I'll Get Saved This Week If You'll Get Saved Next Week

Apr 6, 20260Ep. 11S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments—from a well-meaning church member walking forward during an altar call just to encourage

Show notes

Are Those Seats Taken?

Mar 30, 20260Ep. 10S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments—from longtime church members guarding their “unassigned” pews with the classic line, “You

Show notes

Being a Good Neighbor Goes a Long Way

Mar 23, 20260Ep. 9S-3

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of hilariously chaotic ministry moments—from a church plant pumpkin painting party that ended with the police showing up, to

Show notes

I Had a Whole Year of Training

Mar 16, 20260Ep. 8S-2

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments—from Josh’s early pastoral foot-in-mouth encounter to a sermon illustration that accident

Show notes

Interpretive Dance Ninja Turtle Style

Mar 9, 20260Ep. 7S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share two painfully relatable church moments—from a worship service that suddenly paused while everyone wondered, “Has anyone seen Bob?” to

Show notes

You Should Not be Faint of Heart or Slow of Reflex

Mar 2, 20260Ep. 6S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps share two unforgettable ministry moments—one involving a frantic pastoral check-in and another featuring a hot mic. With plenty of laughs an

Show notes

The Hospital is Where You Get Trained for the Ministry

Feb 23, 20260Ep. 5S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps swap stories that prove ministry is often holier—and messier—than anyone expects. Josh shares a humbling early-ministry moment involving a n

Show notes

I'm Drawing the Line at Fingernails

Feb 16, 20260Ep. 4S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps share a cringe-worthy early-ministry moment involving a crying baby, zero sleep, and a decision that quickly became a lifelong lesson in pas

Show notes

Let Nature Take Its Course

Feb 16, 20260Ep. 3S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share an unforgettable preaching experience in a passionate church—complete with powerful prayers, a multitasking mom, and a perfectly timed

Show notes

The Double Whammy

Feb 9, 20260Ep. 2S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share the legendary tale of “Dr. Mildred,” a charming free-meal enthusiast who somehow found her way into every church event with food on th

Show notes

A Sea of Elvii

Feb 9, 20260Ep. 1S1

In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis swap unbelievable (but totally real) ministry stories—from a funeral filled with Elvis impersonators to a surprisingly “patriotic” wardrobe

Show notes

Trailer

Jan 8, 20260S1

Welcome to the It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast with hosts Matt Capps and Josh Reavis, where you’ll hear unforgettable, awkward, and hilarious stories that could truly only happen to a pastor. Think mic mishaps,

Show notes

Sponsors and advertisers

Sponsor detection runs nightly. Check back soon.

Audience demographics

Age
30-65
Consumer type
Faith community

Topics covered

christianity

Successful pitch examples

No public pitch examples yet for this show.

Generate your own personalised pitch

Best industries to pitch It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast for

Based on semantic analysis of episode topics and host coverage, this show is a strong guest fit for executives in:

Industry fit is computed by PitchCentric using vector embeddings of the show's episode catalog.

Similar podcasts to It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast

Shows with the most semantically similar episode content. Pitch one, pitch all; producers cluster.

Frequently asked questions

How do I pitch It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast as a podcast guest?

To pitch It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast, visit https://www.namb.net/podcasts/itcouldonly for contact information, then craft a tight one-paragraph hook that ties your expertise to a gap in their recent christianity coverage.

Who is the host of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast?

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast is hosted by North American Mission Board. The show is categorised under christianity and has published 13 episodes.

How many episodes does It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast have?

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast has published 13 episodes.

What topics does It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast cover?

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast regularly covers christianity. It sits in the christianity category.

Is it hard to get booked on It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast?

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast is accessible for guests with genuine christianity expertise. A personalised, episode-aware pitch will still outperform a generic one every time.

Is It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast currently accepting guest pitches?

It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast hasn't explicitly signalled guest openness in recent episodes. That doesn't rule out pitching. your hook just needs to be especially compelling and relevant to their recent content.

What guest credentials does It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast typically look for?

Our data rates It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast's guest bar at 80/100 (Premium tier). Established thought leaders with verified media credentials. Sign in to PitchCentric to see how your own Pod Score compares against this show.

Methodology. Booking Probability™ blends Listen Score, 30-day Virality, open-to-guests detection, and Apple ratings. Data refreshed every 60 minutes. Listen Score and Booking Probability are calculated by PitchCentric. Last enriched 9 days ago.

Is this podcast yours and you'd like to remove or correct details? Request removal or email privacy@pitchcentric.com.