Sep 8, 202640 min
Three people. One house. One devastating fire. And a seven-year-old girl caught in the middle of a horrifying Tulsa murder investigation. On October 14, 2018, firefighters responding to a house fire in Tulsa, Oklahoma...
true crime
You Can’t Make This BS Up!
Hosted by Joel · true crime · EN
About this Podcast:
Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Pitch Analysis
Required Pod Score for this podcast. PitchCentric checks your profile against host openness, topical fit, and audience signals before you generate a pitch.
Contact path
Verified email
Booking probability
32%
Guest openness
Selective
80/100
Required Score
Sign up to generate a grounded pitch for You Can’t Make This BS Up!.
Signup to Generate a PitchQuestions about You Can’t Make This BS Up!
What is You Can’t Make This BS Up! about?
Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon
Who hosts You Can’t Make This BS Up!?
You Can’t Make This BS Up! is hosted by Joel. The show has published 65 episodes to date.
What has You Can’t Make This BS Up! covered recently?
Recent episodes include "THE FIRE ON EAST SEMINOLE: The Tulsa Triple Homicide (64)" (8 September 2026, 40 minutes), "JEREMY TREMAINE WILLIAMS & KAMARIE HOLLAND FROM THE BEGINNING TO THE EXECUTION (63)" (15 August 2026, 53 minutes), and "Patrick Wharen: When Love Turns Deadly (62)" (15 August 2026, 45 minutes).
How often does You Can’t Make This BS Up! publish?
You Can’t Make This BS Up! publishes roughly every two weeks, with episodes averaging 42 minutes across 65 episodes.
How hard is it to get booked on You Can’t Make This BS Up!?
Booking probability for You Can’t Make This BS Up! is 32%, and the host is rated Selective on guests. You Can’t Make This BS Up! requires a Pod Score of 80 or higher. You Can’t Make This BS Up!'s contact route on record: verified email.
About the host
Joel hosts You Can’t Make This BS Up!, a true crime podcast with 65 episodes published.
Verified host email: ████████@████.comSign in to unlock →
Recent episodes
Our AI reads these to draft pitches. Use them as grounding for a pitch that cites a real guest and a specific topic.
Aug 15, 202653 minFive-year-old Kamarie Holland should have had her entire life ahead of her. Instead, her name became connected to one of the most disturbing child-murder cases in Alabama and Georgia. In this deeply researched episode...
You Can’t Make This BS Up!
Patrick Wharen: When Love Turns Deadly (62)
Aug 15, 202645 minA marriage falls apart. A family is a caught in the middle. And one day in April 2008 changes everything. In this episode of You Can’t Make This BS Up!, we take a deep dive into the tragic case of Patrick Wharen, a...
Aug 1, 202635 minFormer model Kelsey Turner appeared to be living a glamorous life, posing for magazines and building a social media following. Behind the scenes, however, prosecutors alleged she relied heavily on the financial support...
Episode #60
Pastor Brodes Perry: Broken Promises (60)
Jul 30, 202641 minBrodes C. Perry (age 36 at death) was a third-generation preacher and executive pastor at Mississippi Boulevard Christian Church in Memphis. On April 4, 2019, he and his wife Tabatha were shot in their Collierville...
View More
Jan 30, 202656 minUncover the harrowing true crime story of the Danielle Marshall murder in Powder Springs, Georgia—a chilling case that shocked a quiet Atlanta suburb. In this episode of “You Can’t Make This BS Up,” host Joel Davis...
Jan 19, 202656 minBuckle up for a chilling deep dive into one of Louisiana’s darkest chapters. Host Joel Davis uncovers the twisted life of Derrick Todd Lee, the smooth-talking predator who terrorized Baton Rouge and beyond from...
Episode #57
The Shallow Grave Jealousy Trap (57)
Jan 14, 202631 minWhat happens when a single mom of four tries to move on from a toxic ex… and he decides she can’t? In January 2024, 32-year-old Kayla Laray Atwood drops her kids off at daycare and school in Pensacola, Florida—like any...
Jan 12, 202621 minDive into the heart-wrenching true crime story of Alishah Pointer, a vibrant young woman whose life was stolen on the eve of her 22nd birthday in East Cleveland, Ohio. Uncover the twisted web of revenge, betrayal by a...
Dec 26, 202530 minIn this emotional episode, we delve into the life and tragic death of Breneisha Lightfoot, the talented Cleveland rapper known as Ahlotta. A resilient young woman dedicated to her music, community, and saving lives from...
Episode #54
Onlyfans and her new man took her life. (54)
Dec 11, 202550 minDelve into the chilling North Texas murder-suicide that exposed how one OnlyFans page can shatter lives. Shady Oaks Shadows uncovers Stephanie Ingram’s fierce rise as a mom-turned-creator, her jealous partner Anthony...
Nov 21, 202530 minSummary This episode delves into the tragic story of Raheem Grant, a talented rapper known as Red Beazzy, who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend Sierra Harp. The narrative explores the complexities of their relationship...
Nov 10, 202540 minSummary This podcast episode delves into the chilling story of Nancy Doss, also known as the Giggling Granny, who allegedly killed at least 11 people, including her husbands and family members. The host, Joel, narrates...
Nov 7, 202541 minTakeaways Joel expresses gratitude for listener support and engagement. Nancy Doss, known as Nanny, had a troubled childhood with an abusive father. Nanny's early life was marked by hardship and limited education. She...
Oct 23, 202549 minSummary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic story of Alicia Shane Mills-Lavera and her lover Brett Ray, who conspired to murder her husband, Kelly Lavera. The conversation covers the background of the individuals...
Oct 16, 202548 minSummary In this episode, Joel shares personal updates and dives into the tragic case of Yuri Jenkins, who orchestrated the murder of his wife, Makeeva. The conversation explores the complexities of the trial, the...
Oct 3, 202557 minSummary In this episode, Joel reflects on the growth of his podcast and expresses gratitude to his listeners. He delves into the tragic case of Makaiva Jenkins, a young mother who was murdered in her home. The...
Sep 30, 202532 minSummary This conversation delves into the tragic story of Makava Jenkins, a vibrant entrepreneur and mother whose life was cut short by a violent crime. The host reflects on her background, the community of Belle Glade...
Episode #46
The Murder Case of Sasha Skare (46)
Sep 25, 202533 minSummary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic case of Martell DeRoyan, a rising music producer and cousin of Beyoncé, who was murdered by Sasha Scared, a woman with a troubled past. The conversation explores...
Sep 14, 202557 minSummary The episode delves into the life of Terry Ellis, exploring his troubled past, family dynamics, and the impact of his actions on those around him. It covers his early behavior, family background, violent...
Recent guests
Recent guests on You Can’t Make This BS Up!. Study who booked and why before you pitch.
Best industries to pitch You Can’t Make This BS Up! for
Based on semantic analysis of episode topics and host coverage, this podcast is a strong guest fit for executives in:
true crimestrong
Industry fit is computed by PitchCentric using vector embeddings of the podcast's episode catalog.
Similar Podcasts
Shows with the most semantically similar episode content. Pitch one, pitch all; producers cluster.
Murderosity
26~377 listeners86% similar
What A Killer Podcast
22~308 listeners86% similar
True Crime Storytime
23~332 listeners86% similar
All The Damn Crime
27~392 listeners85% similar
True Crime Stories
29~412 listeners85% similar
True Crime Podcast, Best Stories, Real stories, Investigations, Serial Killer
37~530 listeners85% similar
Podcasts like You Can’t Make This BS Up!
Is this podcast yours and you'd like to remove or correct details? Request removal or email privacy@pitchcentric.com.
Questions about the free trial? See the pricing FAQ