
Episode #54
Appraisal Reality Check
Send us Fan Mail Appraisals nearly derailed multiple deals this year, and that reality is forcing me to get sharper about how I value rental properties, how I structure financing, and how I protect my time. I’m back with a full catch-up after my longest break from posting, and the short version is: I’m still buying. The portfolio is at 126 units, I’ve got about 50 more units under contract, and I’m doing it while working as an airline pilot and a part-time military instructor pilot. We dig into the most frustrating situation first: nine small single-family rentals I bought and improved, then tried to refinance, only to get appraisals that came back painfully low. I explain why comps can fail you, why the income approach and rent performance matter, and what it feels like to carry hard money while you wait weeks for an appraisal that misses obvious upgrades. From there, I walk through a Milwaukee four-unit I bought with hard money and sold almost immediately, plus the unexpected headache of multiple appraisals before the buyer could close. Then we get tactical about liquidity and scaling: selling duplexes to fund new purchases, using a 1031 exchange to defer capital gains taxes, and using cash-out refinances to pull tax-free loan proceeds for down payments while keeping debt manageable. I also share my current strategy shift toward larger, more centralized multifamily, and why staying calm through delays is part of the job when you’re buying and refinancing at scale. If you want more real estate investing updates like this, subscribe, share the episode with a friend, and leave a review. What appraisal or financing problem are you dealing with right now?

