“Not Your Sunday School” is hosted by two friends, Erin & Kaitlyn, who met as yoga practitioners. We didn’t always talk about our faith, but now can’t stop. Each episode, we sit down for casual, honest, sometimes controversial, and often hilarious conversations about what it looks like to live a Christian life outside the lines. We think you'll vibe with us if you're craving something honest, imperfect, and totally real!If you have questions you would like us to answer, would like to be a guest on our podcast, or have a topic you’d like to hear us cover, email us at nyss.podcast@gmail.com
Required Pod Score for this podcast. PitchCentric checks your profile against host openness, topical fit, and audience signals before you generate a pitch.
Contact path
Verified email
Booking probability
32%
Guest openness
Accepting guests
Sign up to generate a grounded pitch for Not Your Sunday School.
Signup to Generate a Pitch“Not Your Sunday School” is hosted by two friends, Erin & Kaitlyn, who met as yoga practitioners. We didn’t always talk about our faith, but now can’t stop. Each episode, we sit down for casual, honest, sometimes controversial, and often hilarious conversations about what it looks like to live a Christian life outside the lines.
Not Your Sunday School is hosted by Erin + Kaitlyn. The show has published 8 episodes to date.
Recent episodes include "NYSS Recap: A Season of Growth, Grace, and Surprises" (5 October 2025, 36 minutes), "What does “lukewarm Christianity” really mean?" (21 September 2025, 52 minutes), and "Do Rituals Still Matter? Finding God in Everyday Practices" (9 September 2025, 34 minutes).
Not Your Sunday School publishes roughly every two weeks, with episodes averaging 46 minutes across 8 episodes.
Booking probability for Not Your Sunday School is 32%, and the host is rated Open on guests. Not Your Sunday School requires a Pod Score of 80 or higher. Not Your Sunday School's contact route on record: verified email.
The strongest fits for Not Your Sunday School are Religion & Faith. Not Your Sunday School has a religion audience.
Erin + Kaitlyn hosts Not Your Sunday School, a religion podcast with 8 episodes published.
Our AI reads these to draft pitches. Use them as grounding for a pitch that cites a real guest and a specific topic.
Not Your Sunday School
Eight episodes in, Erin and Kaitlyn pause to look back on how much life and faith have shifted since they first launched the podcast. From church communities to personal callings, seminary studies to Sunday school...
Not Your Sunday School
What does it really mean to be a “lukewarm Christian”? And how do we know if we’ve slipped into going through the motions instead of living on fire for Christ? In this episode, Erin and Kaitlyn wrestle with a...
Not Your Sunday School
Rituals don’t have to be rigid. They can be deeply personal, grounding, and even surprising ways we connect with God. In this episode, Erin and Kaitlyn open up about the practices that keep them steady: from praying the...
This week’s conversation comes from a listener request. Shoutout to Sydney in Vestavia Hills, Alabama! She asked how social media is shaping Christianity, and Erin and Kaitlyn dive right in. Social media connects us...
Not Your Sunday School
We hear it all the time: “Just pray about it.” But what does that really mean, especially when you're new to faith, coming back, or still unsure what you believe? This episode dives into the practice of prayer, not as a...
Not Your Sunday School
In this episode, Erin confesses something that’s felt taboo in church circles: she really doesn’t like worship music. From the loudness and theatrics to the pressure to “feel something,” it’s never felt like her way in...
Not Your Sunday School
In this episode, Erin takes us through her unconventional path from a science-only worldview to embracing Christianity at age 30. She opens up about years of staunch atheism and how unexpected encounters became the...
We’re kicking off the podcast with Kaitlyn’s story — a vulnerable return to Catholicism that had nothing to do with rules and everything to do with grace. In this episode, she shares her messy, meaningful journey back...
PitchCentric classifies Not Your Sunday School under these industries. Guests from them are the closest fit, and each links to the best podcasts in that industry.
Shows with the most semantically similar episode content. Pitch one, pitch all; producers cluster.
Is this podcast yours and you'd like to remove or correct details? Request removal or email privacy@pitchcentric.com.
Questions about the free trial? See the pricing FAQ
