Mystery Archives Episodes
The Horrifying True Story of Fox Hollow Farm | NEW 2026 Updates
For decades, the secluded property known as Fox Hollow Farm has remained at the center of one of Indiana’s darkest and most disturbing mysteries. Behind the quiet exterior of a sprawling estate in Westfield was a story involving disappearances, unspeakable crimes, hidden human remains, and a man investigators would eventually come to suspect of being responsible for far more than could ever be definitively proven. Years later, the property would become notorious for something else entirely, as new owners, investigators, and visitors began reporting strange activity. They saw shadowy figures moving through the woods, heard unexplained voices and footsteps inside otherwise empty rooms, and witnessed truly disturbing apparitions believed by some to be connected to the people whose remains were discovered scattered throughout the property. Even after all these years, Fox Hollow Farm may still have secrets left to reveal. So tonight, we are going back to the beginning. We’ll examine the life of Herb Baumeister, the disappearances that eventually led investigators to Fox Hollow Farm, the horrifying discoveries that were made, the unanswered questions surrounding additional possible victims, the hauntings, and much more. Then, we’ll bring the story into the present and examine the newest developments in the investigation—including what authorities have learned, which mysteries may finally be closer to being solved, and why the full truth about Fox Hollow Farm may still be emerging. So join me as we dive back into the horrifying true story of Fox Hollow Farm. Please also support me on Youtube & Patreon: https://www.youtube.com/@mysteryarchives https://www.patreon.com/mysteryarchives My Store: www.mysteryarchives.store
