religion
Hosted by Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith · religion · EN-US
Everything Vaguely Paranormal is a paranormal podcast exploring true stories, dark history, and unexplained phenomena. Each episode dives into hauntings, demons, UFOs, witchcraft, and cryptids, breaking down real encounters, folklore, and the patterns that connect them. We focus on what’s documented, what’s reported, and what still can’t be explained. Blending research with conversation, the show balances eerie storytelling with grounded discussion, making space for both skepticism and belief without forcing an answer. If you’re drawn to ghost stories, supernatural cases, and mysteries that linger long after the episode ends, this is where those stories live. New episodes release every Wednesday.
Required Pod Score for this podcast. PitchCentric checks your profile against host openness, topical fit, and audience signals before you generate a pitch.
Contact path
Verified email
Booking probability
37%
Guest openness
Selective
Sign up to generate a grounded pitch for Everything Vaguely Paranormal.
Signup to Generate a PitchEverything Vaguely Paranormal is a paranormal podcast exploring true stories, dark history, and unexplained phenomena. Each episode dives into hauntings, demons, UFOs, witchcraft, and cryptids, breaking down real encounters, folklore, and the patterns that connect them. We focus on what’s documented, what’s reported, and what still can’t be explained.
Everything Vaguely Paranormal is hosted by Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith. The show has published 266 episodes to date.
Recent episodes include "The Watseka Wonder: A Spirit Possession Mystery" (28 October 2026, 123 minutes), "Bloody Benders: Kansas Killers" (21 October 2026, 83 minutes), and "UFO Encounters With Police | Marianne Robb & Dave Rich" (14 October 2026, 65 minutes).
Everything Vaguely Paranormal publishes roughly weekly, with episodes averaging 82 minutes across 266 episodes.
Booking probability for Everything Vaguely Paranormal is 37%, and the host is rated Selective on guests. Everything Vaguely Paranormal requires a Pod Score of 80 or higher. Everything Vaguely Paranormal's contact route on record: verified email.
Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith hosts Everything Vaguely Paranormal, a religion podcast with 266 episodes published.
Our AI reads these to draft pitches. Use them as grounding for a pitch that cites a real guest and a specific topic.
Episode #260
Send us Fan Mail Could the Watseka Wonder be evidence of life after death, or was something far stranger unfolding in a small Illinois town? In 1878, thirteen-year-old Lurancy Vennum began exhibiting unusual behavior...
Episode #259
Send us Fan Mail The Bloody Benders left a trail of death in 1870s Kansas before vanishing. A roadside inn, missing travelers, and claims of spiritualism surround this notorious family. What really happened to the...
Episode #258
Send us Fan Mail What happens when UFO encounters with police challenge what officers can explain? Marianne Robb and Dave Rich explore law enforcement sightings, UAP investigations, paranormal events, and cryptids. Hear...
Episode #257
Send us Fan Mail The Cropsey Urban Legend was a campfire nightmare, until reality began to resemble it. Staten Island children disappeared, and Andre Rand became linked to a name already feared for years. Where did the...
Episode #256
Send us Fan Mail Three Identical Strangers found each other by chance, but their separation hid a darker truth. The triplets had unknowingly been part of a secretive nature vs nurture study. We uncover the secrecy...
Episode #255
Send us Fan Mail Brodhead Manor paranormal investigation takes us back inside Wisconsin's haunted school. Owner Bill Wolter joins us before our September 25–27 public investigation. Hear what we've encountered there...
Episode #254
Send us Fan Mail Dorothy Kilgallen Death remains surrounded by questions decades later. We examine her final hours, the official investigation, missing notes, and disputed evidence. Uncover the documented facts and...
Episode #253
Send us Fan Mail Dorothy Kilgallen became one of America's most respected journalists before becoming a mystery herself. Explore her remarkable career, her growing interest in the Kennedy assassination, and her...
Episode #252
Send us Fan Mail Could walk-in possession leave a physical mark on human DNA? Neal Gibbons presents evidence he believes raises that possibility. We examine the claim, what he has uncovered, and the questions it creates...
Episode #251
Send us Fan Mail Paranormal Research Update begins with a look at what's next for returning guest Larry Eissler. We explore the evolution of the Black Lantern Company and the work currently underway. Discover where his...
Episode #250
Send us Fan Mail How a Paranormal Podcast changed the way we see the unexplained after 250 episodes. After five seasons of investigations, research, and unforgettable experiences, we're looking back at the moments that...
Episode #249
Send us Fan Mail Myrtle Corbin became one of history's most extraordinary sideshow performers. Learn how the four-legged girl captivated audiences through her rare dipygus condition and the life she built beyond the...
Episode #248
Send us Fan Mail Since we last spoke, new experiences and ongoing projects have continued shaping the direction of SVC Explorers of the Unknown. Jack joins us to discuss what's changed, reflect on the journey so far...
Episode #247
Send us Fan Mail True Paranormal Stories brings together brief, viral encounters across time. From Butterfly People said to guide people during the Joplin tornado or the Fresno Nightcrawlers. To an attempt to contact a...
Episode #246
Send us Fan Mail What does life look like as a Psychic Medium? Morgan Caldwell shares personal experiences shaped by the paranormal and her mediumship abilities. Discover the moments that challenged her understanding of...
Episode #245
Send us Fan Mail The Ariel School UFO Incident stands as one of the most debated UFO cases ever reported. In 1994, over 60 children in Zimbabwe described an extraordinary encounter near their school. Explore the...
Episode #244
Send us Fan Mail What can a Psychic Medium reveal about intuition, energy, and spiritual connection? Kris Baughman shares her perspective as an Intuitive Psychic Medium and spiritual practitioner. Discover insights that...
Episode #243
Send us Fan Mail Paranormal Travel in Texas takes center stage as Tay Hamm shares her passion for haunted exploration. We discuss finding and visiting haunted locations and the world of paranormal investigation...
Episode #242
Send us Fan Mail The Flight 191 curse has followed multiple deadly crashes across decades. Different aircraft, different causes, but the same number continues to surface. Explore whether this pattern is coincidence or...
Episode #241
Send us Fan Mail The Villisca Axe Murder House investigation takes us inside one of the most infamous unsolved crimes in America. We explore the 1912 killings, the suspects, and the lasting impact of the Villisca axe...
Recent guests on Everything Vaguely Paranormal. Study who booked and why before you pitch.
Black Lantern Company
Voodoo Authentica
Ghost Geeks
Graveside Paranormal
Based on semantic analysis of episode topics and host coverage, this podcast is a strong guest fit for executives in:
Industry fit is computed by PitchCentric using vector embeddings of the podcast's episode catalog.
Shows with the most semantically similar episode content. Pitch one, pitch all; producers cluster.
Pursuit of the Paranormal
Paranormal Or Reality Experience
Hauntings and Happenings
The Psychic and The Skeptic
Beyond The Veil Podcast
Let's Talk Spooky
Is this podcast yours and you'd like to remove or correct details? Request removal or email privacy@pitchcentric.com.
Questions about the free trial? See the pricing FAQ