
Episode #31
Second Stage ESOP Transactions: Taking a Partial ESOP to 100% Ownership
Many business owners start with an ESOP that owns a minority stake in the company, then later consider selling the rest. This episode covers second stage ESOP transactions: what they are, how they differ from the initial sale, and what owners, management teams, and CFOs should plan for before taking a partial ESOP to 100%. The discussion follows a Northern California specialty grocery company. It sold 40% to its ESOP in 2016, paid off the related debt over five years, and later moved to 100% ESOP ownership in a process that took about a year. The example is used to explain the shift from minority to control valuation, bank and seller financing, Section 1042 eligibility, S corporation considerations, and how to communicate the change to employees. The episode also covers the board governance changes a trustee typically expects at control. It includes audience questions about the 30% threshold for Section 1042 and whether participants own shares directly. It closes with what comes after 100%: the S corporation tax shield, repurchase obligations, re-leverage, and management incentive plans. Hosted by Ben Spadt and Trevor Gilmore of Menke & Associates. Listeners will come away with a clearer picture of the decisions involved in a second stage transaction and why planning early makes a difference. Key Takeaways A second stage transaction is a sale of additional shares to an existing ESOP, and it most often takes the ESOP from a minority stake to 100% ownership. Because the trust, trustee, and plan are already in place, much of the legal groundwork is done, but most second stage deals still take six months to a year. Valuation shifts from a minority basis, which typically includes a discount for lack of control, to a control basis updated for current results and market data. Financing is often a combination of bank debt, seller notes, and company cash, shaped by the seller's cash flow needs and what the company can support. For C corporation sellers, Section 1042 can remain available on later sales once the ESOP owns at least 30% of the company in aggregate. At control, trustees typically expect a more formal board with one or two independent directors, often phased in over about 12 months. New acquisition debt usually lowers share value for a period after closing, and this should be explained clearly to employees. In a 100% ESOP-owned S corporation, no tax distributions are required, which frees cash for debt repayment, reinvestment, and repurchase obligations. Send us Fan Mail Learn more: ESOP Radio: https://www.menke.com/esop-radio/ ESOP Boot Camp: https://www.menke.com/esop-boot-camp/ Confidential feasibility review: https://www.menke.com




