Episode #4
Podcast Update
Jun 12, 20262 minS3
Hey spooky bitches!! I hope to catch you all real soon!! Podcast IG: https://www.instagram.com/but.consider.this/ Lex IG: https://www.instagram.com/lexithemakeupbabe/ Lex Threads...
true crime
But Consider This
Hosted by Lex & Gabby · true crime · EN-US
About this Podcast:
Two spooky girls talking about all things conspiracy theory, murder mystery, or just plain weird.
Pitch Analysis
Required Pod Score for this podcast. PitchCentric checks your profile against host openness, topical fit, and audience signals before you generate a pitch.
Contact path
Public web form
Booking probability
20%
Guest openness
Selective
80/100
Required Score
Sign up to generate a grounded pitch for But Consider This.
Signup to Generate a PitchQuestions about But Consider This
Who hosts But Consider This?
But Consider This is hosted by Lex & Gabby. The show has published 51 episodes to date.
What has But Consider This covered recently?
Recent episodes include "Podcast Update" (12 June 2026, 2 minutes), "Evelyn Hernandez: The First Laci Peterson" (13 June 2025, 42 minutes), and "The Wife Swap Murders" (6 June 2025, 51 minutes).
How often does But Consider This publish?
But Consider This publishes roughly weekly, with episodes averaging 54 minutes across 51 episodes.
How hard is it to get booked on But Consider This?
Booking probability for But Consider This is 20%, and the host is rated Selective on guests. But Consider This requires a Pod Score of 80 or higher. But Consider This's contact route on record: public web form.
About the host
Lex & Gabby hosts But Consider This, a true crime podcast with 51 episodes published.
Host email not verified for this podcastSign in to unlock →
Recent episodes
Our AI reads these to draft pitches. Use them as grounding for a pitch that cites a real guest and a specific topic.
Episode #3
Evelyn Hernandez: The First Laci Peterson
Jun 13, 202542 minS3<p>Hey spooky bitches!!</p><p>Today we're talking about the absolutely heartbreaking case of Evelyn Hernandez and her two missing sons. What do you think happened?</p><p>TRIGGER WARNING: Mentions of abuse and deaths of...
Episode #2
The Wife Swap Murders
Jun 6, 202551 minS3<p>Hey spooky bitches!</p><p>Today we're talking the Stockdale family, who were featured on Wife Swap, and their murders! Was the show a catalyst for the entire event? Let us know what you think!</p><p>Podcast IG...
Episode #1
We're Back!!
May 30, 202539 minS3<p>Hello spooky bitches!!</p><p>After an (accidental) hiatus, we are back!! Thank you so much for sticking with us, missing us, and supporting us!!</p><p>Caiti's Band...
But Consider This
Spook Rock: Local Lethal
Mar 22, 20241 hourS0<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>Today Gabby is sharing a local lethal from her hometown! It's not just a boulder, it's a rock!</p><p>Podcast IG: https://www.instagram.com/but.consider.this/<br/><br/>Gabby IG...
View More
Episode #3
Mini Local Lethal + Nonsense
Mar 15, 202439 minS2<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>Today Lex has a quickie local story followed by a lot of chit chat and nonsense. Let us know if you'd like more episodes where we just chat!!</p><p>Podcast IG...
Episode #2
The Atrocious Murder of Shad Thyrion
Mar 8, 202449 minS2<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>TRIGGER WARNING: ABUSE OF A CORPSE, MUTILATION, NECROPHILIA<br/><br/>Today we're talking about to absolutely atrocious murder of Shad Thyrion at the hands of Taylor Schabusiness. Let us...
Episode #1
Gypsy Rose Blanchard
Mar 1, 20241h 18mS2<p>Hey spooky bitches!! We're back!!<br/><br/>Thank you so much for being patient with us while we took an unexpectedly long hiatus; we appreciate you all!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about the controversial case of...
Episode #44
Five Nights At Freddy's
Nov 10, 20231h 19mS1<p>MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THE FNAF MOVIE<br/><br/>Hello spooky bitches! Today we're talking about the Five Nights At Freddy's movies and games! Did you like the movie? Did you play the games? Let us know all your...
Episode #43
The Saw Franchise
Oct 20, 20231h 21mS1<p>SPOILERS FOR SAW X<br/><br/>MAJOR SPOILERS<br/><br/>Hey spooky bitches! Today we're taking a deep dive into the world of Saw! THERE WILL BE SPOILERS FOR SAW X. You have been warned!! Let us know what your favorite...
Episode #42
Sherri Papini: The Vanishing Act
Sep 29, 202350 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>Today we're discussing the disappearance of Sherri Papini that later turned out to be a hoax! Let us know what you think!</p><p>Podcast IG...
But Consider This
The Devastating Murder of Sophie Lancaster
Sep 15, 20231h 32mS0<p>Hey spooky bitches!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about the absolutely heartbreaking murder of goth teen Sophie Lancaster. Would you consider this a hate crime? Let us know all your thoughts!</p><p>Podcast IG...
Episode #40
The Kidnapping Hoax of Carlee Russell
Sep 8, 202327 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about the very recent and very confusing case of Carlee Russell's fake kidnapping! Let us know all your theories about why she did this and where she...
Episode #39
Disney Conspiracies & Chit Chat
Aug 11, 202358 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>Today we're breaking up our usual gruesome and upsetting content with something more lighthearted, Disney! Let us know any of your Disney conspiracies! Do you believe in any of the ones...
Episode #38
The Curious Death of Jeannette DePalma
Aug 4, 202328 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>UPDATE: There will be a prayer vigil for Jeannette on Monday, August 7th 2023 at 7pm - 8pm on the steps of Springfield Town Hall (100 Mountain Ave, Springfield NJ 07081)<br/><br/>Today...
Episode #37
Stockholm Syndrome: The Norrmalmstorg Robbery
Jul 28, 202341 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about the origins of Stockholm syndrome, the Norrmalmstorg robbery! Let us know what you think about this absolutely wild case! Do you think Belle has Stockholm...
Episode #36
Natalia Grace ft Bianca
Jul 14, 20231h 31mS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!!<br/><br/>Today our friend Bianca joins the pod for a much heated discussion about the tragic and confusing story of Natalia Grace! Let us know your thoughts on this curious case!<br/><br/>GoFund...
Episode #35
Dorothea Puente: The Death House Landlady
Jul 7, 202353 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches! Today we're talking about the absolutely insane story of Dorothea Puente! Let us know all your thoughts on this case!<br/><br/>TRIGGER WARNING: Mentions of suicide, sexual assault, and abuse of...
Episode #34
The Ken & Barbie Killers
Jun 23, 20231h 31mS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka aka the Ken and Barbie killers! Do you think Karla enjoyed being involved? Let us know all your thoughts!<br/><br/>TRIGGER...
Episode #33
The Burger Chef Murders
Jun 16, 202334 minS1<p>Hey spooky bitches!<br/><br/>Today we're talking about the tragic murders of four young employees of an old restaurant chain called Burger Chef! Who do you think did it? Let us know your thoughts!<br/><br/>Crime...
Recent guests
Recent guests on But Consider This. Study who booked and why before you pitch.
Best industries to pitch But Consider This for
Based on semantic analysis of episode topics and host coverage, this podcast is a strong guest fit for executives in:
true crimestrong
Industry fit is computed by PitchCentric using vector embeddings of the podcast's episode catalog.
Similar Podcasts
Shows with the most semantically similar episode content. Pitch one, pitch all; producers cluster.
Podcasts like But Consider This
Is this podcast yours and you'd like to remove or correct details? Request removal or email privacy@pitchcentric.com.
Questions about the free trial? See the pricing FAQ